Comparing Methods For (Remote) Access

DNS-based

Hint

This is clearly the best and most secure approach and we recommend using a DNS-based remote-access method including your own TLS certificate for the best security

This denotes the Dynamic DNS Setup and the Static DNS Configuration approach.

  • Clearly the best method, but also the one requiring some configuration work on your internet router.

  • You get your own (sub)domain and a TLS certificate, thus all your traffic will always be end-to-end encrypted and you maintain the highest level of security for your traffic.

  • Opening the right ports on your internet router is necessary, see here

  • Data path: [NextBox] ⟷ [Router] ⟷ [Client]

  • Pro: best performance, highest security, full end-to-end encryption

  • Contra: needs (dynamic) DNS, needs configuration on your internet router

Non-encrypted

Warning

We strongly recommend to not use the non-encrypted setup, if you plan to make your NextBox available outside of your local area network.

  • simple (http) using either nextbox.local or your local IP (e.g.: 192.168.178.123)

  • Generally a bad idea, this will not encrypt the transported data in any way and is only useful in a setup where you do not want remote access to your NextBox (having non-encrypted traffic inside your LAN might be no problem, as long as you know what you are doing)

  • Data path: [NextBox] ⟷ [Router] ⟷ [Client]

  • Pro: fast, no configuration

  • Contra: no transport security, no remote access (or only unencrypted)

Further, once you set up TLS and thus a DNS-based method, the unencrypted connection for your NextBox will be disabled, this is not the case for the Reverse Proxy as a problem with the proxy would then lock you out of your NextBox.

Nitrokey’s Reverse Proxy

This refers to the Backwards Proxy Remote Access method.

  • Provides transport encryption between your clients and your NextBox. But with the drawback that it is not End-To-End encrypted, means the traffic will be decrypted at the Nitrokey Proxy Server and passed onward with another encryption. Thus a compromised proxy server might allow access to your traffic to the potential attacker.

  • The proxy server is a bottleneck and all traffic has to go through the proxy server, even if you are in a local network together with the NextBox the traffic has to go through the proxy server.

  • Data path (local client): [NextBox] ⟷ [Router]⟷ [Proxy Server] ⟷ [Router] ⟷ [Client]

  • Data path (remote client): [NextBox] ⟷ [Router]⟷ [Proxy Server] ⟷ [Client]

  • Pro: easy to setup, good transport security

  • Contra: not strictly end-to-end encrypted, potentially slow (all traffic through the proxy)

Hint

Non end-to-end encrypted does still mean all your traffic is indeed encrypted, but within the proxy server, in order to be forwarded the traffic will be decrypted once and encrypted again before being passed to the client or NextBox